The Selection of the UN Secretary-General: Between United Nations Principles and the Interests of the Powerful

 

Dr Inas Mohamed Ahmed
The selection of the Secretary-General of the United Nations is a highly significant legal and political process, resembling in many respects an international election in which several candidates compete for the UN’s top post before the organisation’s 193 member states. It brings together the provisions of the UN Charter and international law with the competing interests of states and the influence wielded by certain major powers. Consequently, member states do not carry equal weight in determining the final outcome and selecting the new Secretary-General.
As António Guterres’s term of office approaches its end on 31 December 2026, the United Nations is engaged in the contest to select its tenth Secretary-General. The process includes public sessions in which each candidate can present themselves and demonstrate their abilities, experience, skills, and professional record. These open and transparent presentations are intended to help identify the best candidate for the position.
It is established practice that the UN Charter does not specify the duration of the Secretary-General’s term of office. However, convention has settled on a five-year term, renewable for a further five years. To date, no Secretary-General has served more than two terms.
This senior administrative position at the head of the United Nations requires candidates to meet specific conditions and qualifications, all of which must be fulfilled procedurally.
Legally, the appointment of the Secretary-General is governed by the UN Charter, which entrusts the Security Council with recommending a candidate to the General Assembly for appointment. This makes the Security Council’s approval a decisive and fundamental element of the selection process.
Politically, however, the nomination process is subject to a range of considerations relating to international interests and the positions of member states, particularly the five permanent members of the Security Council. This means that the process reflects the intersection between international power balances and the interests of major states, on the one hand, and the legal requirements of the United Nations as an institution and its adherence to the Charter, on the other.
The UN Charter regulates the selection of the Secretary-General under Article 97, which states: “The Secretariat shall comprise a Secretary-General and such staff as the Organisation may require. The Secretary-General shall be appointed by the General Assembly upon the recommendation of the Security Council.”
This provision makes clear that the selection process is a two-stage procedure: the General Assembly makes the appointment on the recommendation of the Security Council. This interpretation was confirmed by the advisory opinion issued on 3 March 1950, which affirmed that the Security Council’s recommendation constitutes an essential, prior and binding procedural requirement before the General Assembly can proceed with the selection of the Secretary-General.
From a legislative perspective, the provision’s wording is brief and concise, establishing a limited legal framework for the selection process. At the same time, however, it leaves room for the development of international customary rules governing its practical implementation. These customary rules have gradually evolved and become established over time, forming a procedural framework for the selection process.
Over recent decades, a number of factors have brought about a positive shift towards greater transparency in the various stages of selecting the UN Secretary-General. At the heart of this development was General Assembly Resolution 69/321, adopted on 11 September 2015. This was a landmark resolution for several reasons:
It helped develop the mechanism for selecting the Secretary-General. The nomination process now begins with the circulation of a single, jointly issued official letter addressed to all member states.
Candidates are required to present their visions through public, informal dialogues and discussions, allowing all member states to engage with them transparently rather than relying on previous practices.
It strengthened the role of the General Assembly and promoted geographical and gender balance by encouraging member states to nominate women candidates as well, thereby advancing equal opportunities and diversity.
This approach was used for the first time during the General Assembly’s seventieth session, when clear and transparent nomination procedures were followed, allowing civil society to engage with the candidates. The process culminated in the appointment of António Guterres as Secretary-General on 13 October 2016 for a five-year term. His mandate was subsequently renewed and is due to end on 31 December 2026.
As part of the organisation’s continuing internal reform, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 79/327 in 2025, building on the previous reform measures. The resolution allows nominations to be submitted either by an individual member state or by a group of states jointly proposing a single candidate. Candidates are required to submit a statement outlining their vision, their curriculum vitae and the sources of funding for their campaigns. Their appointment, however, remains entirely dependent on a recommendation from the Security Council.
Observers will note that, in the current round, several women have been nominated from Chile, Costa Rica, Ecuador and Guyana, a country in South America, while male candidates have been nominated from Argentina and Uganda.
All the candidates have substantial political and specialised international experience, with long records of diplomatic and international service. However, the competition is not confined to each candidate’s political credentials. It also extends to the nature of their experience and the relevance of their particular areas of expertise in addressing the growing challenges facing the United Nations, in the context of international power balances, competing interests and current global issues.
One distinguishing feature of this selection round is the presence of several women candidates, which could increase the likelihood of a woman being appointed Secretary-General for the first time. Since the United Nations’ establishment in 1945, the position has been held by nine men in succession.
The presence of candidates from Latin America and the Caribbean brings regional considerations into the equation, and these may prove influential. Similarly, nominating an African candidate raises the question of selection against the backdrop of international balance, particularly given the growing activity of the African Group within the United Nations.
The choice of candidate this time, therefore, may not rest solely on competence and experience. Considerations of geographical and social representation may also come into play, alongside other international characteristics, capabilities and power balances.
Furthermore, the requirement for a Security Council recommendation gives the veto powers of the five permanent members a significant and exceptional influence over the selection process. Each candidate must secure at least nine votes from the Council’s fifteen members, but must also avoid objections from any permanent member.
The Security Council conducts an informal, non-binding ballot known as a straw poll to gauge support for each candidate within the Council. Members can indicate whether they encourage or discourage a candidate, or choose not to express an opinion. Historically, however, the Council has tended to submit only one name to the General Assembly, rather than a list of candidates from which the Assembly can choose. In other words, the Security Council selects its preferred candidate and forwards that name to the General Assembly to complete and formally announce the appointment.
Another fundamental point is that, although there is no legally binding rule requiring the position to rotate among the world’s different regions, UN practice has generally taken geographical distribution into account. This factor has acquired particular importance in the current selection process.
In conclusion, the world now needs a candidate capable of responding to current international crises in an unconventional, swift and decisive manner, and one who believes in the need to reform and develop the United Nations itself so that it can keep pace with the challenges posed by humanitarian issues and conditions across the world.
Nevertheless, we must remain realistic and recognise that, although the Secretary-General’s position is primarily bureaucratic in nature, the Charter gives its holder considerable political and diplomatic scope in which to operate. The post has historically been associated with mediation, persistent efforts to resolve crises and diplomatic initiatives to settle disputes. This explains why the major powers take such a keen interest in the person who will occupy it.
One final point concerns Abu Dhabi’s nomination of Minister Lana Zaki Nusseibeh, an Emirati diplomat of Palestinian origin, for the position of UN Secretary-General, succeeding António Guterres. This is the first time the United Arab Emirates has put forward a candidate for the post. The move may be intended to improve Abu Dhabi’s reputation in international forums. It may also reflect the candidate’s qualifications for the position and the UAE’s decision to nominate a woman, in keeping with growing calls for a woman to take the helm of the United Nations. This is so despite opposition to her nomination from some parliamentary and human rights voices.
Ultimately, the selection process will remain subject to international power balances, bargaining, complex intersections and conflicting interests. The decision will be made according to the calculations of the fifteen members of the Security Council, particularly the five permanent members with veto powers.
The decision will not be automatic, rushed or accidental. Rather, it will shape the fundamental direction of United Nations policy in the coming period, shaped by the five powers holding the veto and guided by their respective interests.

Shortlink: https://sudanhorizon.com/?p=20421